Over-packaging is costing you money: how to right-size your cartons

By Adithya G Udupa, 21 October 2026

Most manufacturers know their packaging costs too much. Fewer know exactly how much, or where the waste is coming from. One of the most common and most fixable sources of waste is over-packaging — cartons that are significantly larger than the product they contain.

What over-packaging actually costs

When a carton is larger than it needs to be, you pay for the extra board in three ways:

Board cost. Every extra square centimetre of board costs money. For a manufacturer using 50,000 cartons per year, a 20% reduction in board area per carton translates directly to a 20% reduction in board spend.

Freight cost. Larger cartons mean fewer cartons per pallet, which means more pallets per shipment, which means higher freight cost per unit. This is separate from the board cost and often larger.

Carbon footprint. Board production is carbon-intensive. The typical emission factor for corrugated board is around 0.7 kg CO2e per kg of board produced. If your annual board consumption is 50,000 kg, that is 35 tonnes of CO2e — before you account for the extra freight.

The EU PPWR empty-space rule

The EU Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR), which came into force in 2024, sets a maximum empty-space ratio of 50% for e-commerce and transport packaging sold into the EU market. If more than half the internal volume of your carton is empty, it does not comply.

This matters for Indian exporters. If you are shipping to Europe, your packaging needs to meet this standard. And even if you are not, the 50% rule is a useful benchmark — if your carton is more than half empty, you almost certainly have a right-sizing opportunity.

Check your empty space with our free calculator →

How to calculate empty space

The calculation is straightforward:

Empty space (%) = 1 − (product volume / box volume)

Product volume = product length × width × height.
Box volume = box internal length × width × height.

A product measuring 200 × 150 × 100 mm (volume = 3,000,000 mm³) in a box measuring 350 × 280 × 220 mm (volume = 21,560,000 mm³) has an empty space of 1 − (3,000,000 / 21,560,000) = 86%. That is well over the PPWR limit and represents a significant right-sizing opportunity.

How to calculate board savings

The board area of a regular slotted carton (RSC) blank can be estimated as:

Board area (m²) = ((2L + 2W + 35) × (H + W)) / 1,000,000

Where L, W and H are the internal box dimensions in mm, and 35 mm accounts for the manufacturer's joint.

Board weight per box = board area × GSM / 1000.
Annual board weight = board weight per box × annual volume.

If you know your board price per kg, you can calculate annual board cost directly. A suggested right-sized box adds 10 mm to each product dimension (5 mm clearance each side). Running the same calculation for the smaller box gives you the annual saving.

A worked example

Product: 200 × 150 × 100 mm. Current box: 350 × 280 × 220 mm. Board GSM: 450. Annual volume: 50,000 boxes. Board price: ₹55 per kg.

Current box:

  • Empty space: 86%
  • Board area: ((700 + 560 + 35) × (220 + 280)) / 1,000,000 = 0.6475 m²
  • Board per box: 0.6475 × 450 / 1000 = 0.291 kg
  • Annual board: 0.291 × 50,000 = 14,575 kg
  • Annual cost: 14,575 × 55 = ₹8,01,625
  • Annual CO2e: 14,575 × 0.7 = 10,203 kg

Suggested box (210 × 160 × 110 mm):

  • Board area: ((420 + 320 + 35) × (110 + 160)) / 1,000,000 = 0.2093 m²
  • Board per box: 0.2093 × 450 / 1000 = 0.094 kg
  • Annual board: 0.094 × 50,000 = 4,710 kg
  • Annual cost: 4,710 × 55 = ₹2,59,050
  • Annual CO2e: 4,710 × 0.7 = 3,297 kg

Annual saving: ₹5,42,575 in board cost and 6,906 kg CO2e.

That is a significant saving from a simple design change. The actual saving in a real project would also include freight savings from better pallet utilisation, which can be comparable in size.

What to do next

Right-sizing a carton is not just about making it smaller. You need to verify that the smaller box still provides adequate protection — that the product does not move around during transit, that the board grade is appropriate for the new dimensions, and that the box still passes any required transit tests.

The right sequence is:

  1. Calculate the empty space and potential saving.
  2. Define the right-sized box dimensions (product + clearance for cushioning or dunnage).
  3. Check the compression strength of the new box against your stacking and storage requirements.
  4. Prototype and test before committing to production.

Calculate your empty space and potential savings →

Talk to an engineer about right-sizing your packaging →

Try the Right-Size Calculator

Want an engineer to check your pack?

Book a free 30-min call and we'll look at it together.

Book a free call